erintowner's review

Go to review page

5.0

Wow, I really liked this one! Granted, I am the target audience--Im interested in true crime and epidemiology. I thought it might either be dry or overly lurid but the book described the main players in the case engagingly. Waneta Hoyt--holy cannoli. What an interesting specimen. I know how I feel about the verdict but this book shows how even fairly black and white court cases can be difficult to sentence. Highly recommend.

wolfshine's review

Go to review page

4.0

I’ve listened to quite a few true crime books, so I had some expectations going into this book. It was okay, but I like when true crime books focus on the event that’s mentioned in the title. There was a long history in this book of babies dying from what appeared to be SIDS on a farm and then a few hours of medical discussion about this diagnosis.

The discussion of the other cases sort of took away from the idea of the book. I wanted to learn more about Waneta Hoyt’s life and why she was eventually driven to kill all five of her children. I understand it was all important background information in setting the grounds for Hoyt’s arrest, but it was hard for me to get into this book. I had to listen in little sections which is unusual for me for a book of this genre.

Narration saved it for me.

This book was given to me for free at my request and I provided this voluntary review.
More...