Scan barcode
lordofthemoon's review
3.0
The second volume of Space Helmet for a Cow takes up the story from where the first volume leaves off: Doctor Who has been cancelled and that looks like that. Talking us through the Wilderness Years, to its triumphant return and beyond, Kirkley retains the informal, chatty style from the first book that makes this as easy to read as that volume.
There is, however, a major issue with this volume, which Kirkley acknowledges in the introduction, is that this is all still comparatively recently. Doctor Who returned in 2005, that's just twelve years ago, at the time of this review. There hasn't been time for things to come out in the wash yet, so we still don't have the full story behind Christopher Eccleston's short time in the Tardis, or why Freema Agyeman left after just one year. And that just gets worse, the closer to the present day that we get. By the time we're up to Eleven's last series (and the afterword, that discusses Twelve's first couple of seasons), it's become just a glorified episode guide, with a ratings count. That's not to take anything away from the work that Kirkley has put in, but I'd be much more interested in the second edition of Space Helmet Vol 2, that emerges in another couple of decades.
There's still some good stories behind the scenes, and some running gags at the expense of former BBC director general Michael Grade (and Adric. I would say poor Adric, but, well, it's Adric). But it's not as essential a volume as its predecessor. And it could still do with an index.
There is, however, a major issue with this volume, which Kirkley acknowledges in the introduction, is that this is all still comparatively recently. Doctor Who returned in 2005, that's just twelve years ago, at the time of this review. There hasn't been time for things to come out in the wash yet, so we still don't have the full story behind Christopher Eccleston's short time in the Tardis, or why Freema Agyeman left after just one year. And that just gets worse, the closer to the present day that we get. By the time we're up to Eleven's last series (and the afterword, that discusses Twelve's first couple of seasons), it's become just a glorified episode guide, with a ratings count. That's not to take anything away from the work that Kirkley has put in, but I'd be much more interested in the second edition of Space Helmet Vol 2, that emerges in another couple of decades.
There's still some good stories behind the scenes, and some running gags at the expense of former BBC director general Michael Grade (and Adric. I would say poor Adric, but, well, it's Adric). But it's not as essential a volume as its predecessor. And it could still do with an index.
More...