Scan barcode
timinbc's review
3.0
More of the same, I guess. A rollicking adventure, quite fun if you ignore the savage beating that science takes. I think there are too many characters, but I admit that a five-book series needs them.
The many threads of character development are well done here, especially if we remember that we're aiming YA here.
I had trouble last book with Thomas building a laser on a table, one that forms visible red beams and requires only a household power source. We knew that the weapon requires a jewel; this time we learn that it consumes the jewel as if it were fuel. Hmm. AND .. with hours to go till the showdown, KNOWING we need the Magic Tommy Gun, he casually asks the ambassador, "Dude, any chance you have a huge, perfect diamond," and the amb is all "no worries, mate" and hands one over.
The High Garda are powerful, well trained, and dedicated. If we weren't constantly being reminded of that, this series could have been four books.
The automata are complicated, and we are frequently reminded how mean and nasty they are; but in the end they're about as annoying as bees for our heroes. And don't get me started on the mechanical dragon with its unspecified power source, apparent AI controller, implausible size (scales the size of troop carriers?), and enormous weapon-fuel capability. Hey. at least it didn't have an easily-reached off switch.
Poor suffering Wolfe and Nic were a good idea, but they got bathetic in this one and stayed there.
This all sounds negative, but in the end I rather enjoyed finding all the silly. And on the whole, it's a story you want to know the end of. So yes, I will read #5, in honour of Caine's career. R.I.P. Rachel.
The many threads of character development are well done here, especially if we remember that we're aiming YA here.
I had trouble last book with Thomas building a laser on a table, one that forms visible red beams and requires only a household power source. We knew that the weapon requires a jewel; this time we learn that it consumes the jewel as if it were fuel. Hmm. AND .. with hours to go till the showdown, KNOWING we need the Magic Tommy Gun, he casually asks the ambassador, "Dude, any chance you have a huge, perfect diamond," and the amb is all "no worries, mate" and hands one over.
The High Garda are powerful, well trained, and dedicated. If we weren't constantly being reminded of that, this series could have been four books.
The automata are complicated, and we are frequently reminded how mean and nasty they are; but in the end they're about as annoying as bees for our heroes. And don't get me started on the mechanical dragon with its unspecified power source, apparent AI controller, implausible size (scales the size of troop carriers?), and enormous weapon-fuel capability. Hey. at least it didn't have an easily-reached off switch.
Poor suffering Wolfe and Nic were a good idea, but they got bathetic in this one and stayed there.
This all sounds negative, but in the end I rather enjoyed finding all the silly. And on the whole, it's a story you want to know the end of. So yes, I will read #5, in honour of Caine's career. R.I.P. Rachel.
tracilynn33's review against another edition
adventurous
inspiring
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
kathydavie's review against another edition
5.0
Fourth in The Great Library series and revolving around a small corps of Scholars and Garda who refuse to accept the corruption at the heart of the Great Library.
My Take
It's a game of cat-and-mouse with betrayals zinging everywhere. Using third-person global subjective point-of-view, Caine provides access into the minds of a number of recurring characters with the primary perspective being Jess'.
The story is rank with power-mad people, and the destruction they wreak to enjoy that power. A prime example of what happens when the people rise up against tyranny.
Ooh, Caine pokes away at that male myth that women can't handle too much learning. You go, girl! More "myths" include that truism of someone who says "believe me" who will do the opposite, just as someone who says they always tell the truth or never lie, are out and out liars. Lol, just like people who introduce themselves to me as being "Christians". They make me want to run in the other direction, as they're the least Christian people who exist.
It's quite the busy time for Jess, Brendan, Wolfe, and Morgan, as our core characters intend to save the Library, not destroy it. Nor will they accept outside help if that could be the result. Naturally, the rebelling countries are more interested in their gaining power, through whoever in yet another disaster bearing down on them.
The Story
The Great Library is rotten from the top down, and this deal for valuable books, thousands of them, to be delivered to Callum Brightwell in London, is a betrayal. In exchange, Jess' father will destroy his printing press. Yet another betrayal.
It's an unacceptable trade in so many ways, with the Great Library betraying its own mission while the destruction of that printing press prevents people from owning, having, being out from under the censorship of the Library.
The Characters
Jess Brightwell had become a High Garda until he rebelled against the Library; he's also his father's heir. He has a twin, Brendan, a.k.a., Scraps, who has way fewer morals. Liam had been their older brother, until he was caught.
The rebellious ones include…
…Jess and Research Scholar Christopher Wolfe and Obscurist Morgan Hault who were returned to the Library by "Brendan". Wolfe is in a dungeon with other jailed Scholars — Marcus Johnson is a Scholar Artifex, Le Dinh is a Scholar Medica, Scholar Maria Kent is one of the exceptional prisoners, Captain Ahmed Khan and Lieutenant Ariane Daskalakis are High Garda along with five others, several Scholars from Literature, an author, and various librarians including Kima from Leeds. Niccolo Santi is Wolfe's lover and a highly respected captain of the High Garda.
Thomas Schreiber, a German Scholar Artifex, is mad for the mechanical and invented a printing press. Glain Wathen is Welsh and the ideal High Garda. Khalila Seif is another Scholar and very bright. Her loyal family — Saleh is a younger brother, the older brother and a younger sister, and her father and uncle &8212; has been arrested by the Archivist.
Dario Santiago also became one of the High Garda along with Glain. Dario's cousins are the king and queen of Spain (Ramón Alfonse) and, Alvaro Santiago, the Spanish ambassador to the Great Library. "Brother Ferdinand" is a poor Franciscan monk.
The Great Library, Alexandria, Egypt, is…
…the repository of all books and all knowledge, strictly guarded by the Library, books that may only be borrowed through the Obscurist-created "WiFi" to appear on Blanks. The Archivist Magister is the head of the Library and is greedy to keep all the power. Neksa is the Archivist's assistant. The Curia consists of the heads of the major disciplines within the Library and complicit in all that he's done. Thomas Qualls is the Master of Cells, the Library's chief torturer. The Artifex Magnus, second in power, is in charge of manufacturing weapons and automatons. Captain Chu is an unworthy High Commander.
Serapeum are daughter libraries and are Library territory with their own laws, think "embassy". Hmmm, the Serapeum in Cadiz was designed by Gaudí. The widely respected Scholar Murasaki Shirasu is in charge in Cadiz. Fergus is the High Garda commander in Cadiz. Lieutenant Kali.
The Lighthouse is…
…headquarters for most of the Scholars. Scholar Parker is a Medica. Scholar Yang is not who they think.
The Feast of Greater Burning is a public execution of the Archivist's enemies.
The Iron Tower is…
…a prison for Obscurists, the magic users who make it possible for this world's tablets, the Blanks, to fill. The sadistic Gregory is the new Obscurist Magnus, third in power. Captain Nofret Alamsi is in charge of Tower security. The nasty Fratelli is the Master Copyist. Gregory intends for Benjamin Argent to breed with Morgan. The Black Archives had been a storehouse for forbidden knowledge.
Annis is the least-talented Obscurist and set to watch Morgan. She is known for her lovemaking, and Pyotr and Bjorn, who loves to play music, are some of her lovers. Friedrich and Millicent Thorpe are servants in the Tower. Natasha works with the Codex monitoring script.
Obscurist Magnus Keria Morning had been Magnus previous to Gregory. Obscurist Eskander has lived as a hermit in the Iron Tower for the past 40 years. They are Wolfe's parents.
The Garda are…
…divided into the Elite, fanatics who protect only one man, and the High, like Jess, who protect the Library and its sister Libraries throughout the world. Lieutenant Zara Cole had been under Santi. Lieutenant Tom "Troll" Rolleson had been in charge of the Blue Dogs and a friend of Jess' as was Centurion Botha.
The Enemy
Burners are rebels all over the world who believe that books, real books, should be available to anyone. That they should be able to own books for a personal library.
Smugglers supply real books to anyone who can pay. Callum Brightwell is Jess' and Brendan's grasping father, a smuggler of books who is based in London.
Red Ibrahim is one of the biggest, most notorious book smugglers — his public business is in shipping and storage — and is based in Alexandria. The fourteen-year-old Anit is his daughter and his heir, sailing back to Alexandria in the Valiant Isis with Santi, Khalila, Dario, and Glain her prisoners. Red Ibrahim's lieutenants include Tadalesh.
Elisinore Quest is a skilled Mesmer (hypnotist).
The Treaty of Pergamum is the foundational document that ensured the Great Library's neutrality. Until now, as Spain, Wales, England, Portugal, Turkey, Russia, Japan, the exiled queen of France, and the United Colonies of America have all pulled out. Codexes are like the Internet, passing news back and forth. The Translation Chambers are similar to a Star Trek-style transporter.
The Cover and Title
The cover is a broken library wall that's taken out the top edges of a shelf of ancient books, but that too is only a cover for what the Great Library is hiding in their black corruption. The hole itself is jagged but for the top edge, a silhouette of sphinxes facing each other, tails swishing. A pair of info blurbs are at the top in a pale yellow with the author's name directly below it in an embossed white in a gothic-style font. The title is inside the black hole with much fancier initial caps in an aged gradient of golden brown to vintage yellow. A smaller slash below that reveals the series information.
The title is metaphorical with the "smoke" of Jess' charade and the "iron" being Morgan's part in Smoke and Iron.
My Take
It's a game of cat-and-mouse with betrayals zinging everywhere. Using third-person global subjective point-of-view, Caine provides access into the minds of a number of recurring characters with the primary perspective being Jess'.
The story is rank with power-mad people, and the destruction they wreak to enjoy that power. A prime example of what happens when the people rise up against tyranny.
Ooh, Caine pokes away at that male myth that women can't handle too much learning. You go, girl! More "myths" include that truism of someone who says "believe me" who will do the opposite, just as someone who says they always tell the truth or never lie, are out and out liars. Lol, just like people who introduce themselves to me as being "Christians". They make me want to run in the other direction, as they're the least Christian people who exist.
It's quite the busy time for Jess, Brendan, Wolfe, and Morgan, as our core characters intend to save the Library, not destroy it. Nor will they accept outside help if that could be the result. Naturally, the rebelling countries are more interested in their gaining power, through whoever in yet another disaster bearing down on them.
The Story
The Great Library is rotten from the top down, and this deal for valuable books, thousands of them, to be delivered to Callum Brightwell in London, is a betrayal. In exchange, Jess' father will destroy his printing press. Yet another betrayal.
It's an unacceptable trade in so many ways, with the Great Library betraying its own mission while the destruction of that printing press prevents people from owning, having, being out from under the censorship of the Library.
The Characters
Jess Brightwell had become a High Garda until he rebelled against the Library; he's also his father's heir. He has a twin, Brendan, a.k.a., Scraps, who has way fewer morals. Liam had been their older brother, until he was caught.
The rebellious ones include…
…Jess and Research Scholar Christopher Wolfe and Obscurist Morgan Hault who were returned to the Library by "Brendan". Wolfe is in a dungeon with other jailed Scholars — Marcus Johnson is a Scholar Artifex, Le Dinh is a Scholar Medica, Scholar Maria Kent is one of the exceptional prisoners, Captain Ahmed Khan and Lieutenant Ariane Daskalakis are High Garda along with five others, several Scholars from Literature, an author, and various librarians including Kima from Leeds. Niccolo Santi is Wolfe's lover and a highly respected captain of the High Garda.
Thomas Schreiber, a German Scholar Artifex, is mad for the mechanical and invented a printing press. Glain Wathen is Welsh and the ideal High Garda. Khalila Seif is another Scholar and very bright. Her loyal family — Saleh is a younger brother, the older brother and a younger sister, and her father and uncle &8212; has been arrested by the Archivist.
Dario Santiago also became one of the High Garda along with Glain. Dario's cousins are the king and queen of Spain (Ramón Alfonse) and, Alvaro Santiago, the Spanish ambassador to the Great Library. "Brother Ferdinand" is a poor Franciscan monk.
The Great Library, Alexandria, Egypt, is…
…the repository of all books and all knowledge, strictly guarded by the Library, books that may only be borrowed through the Obscurist-created "WiFi" to appear on Blanks. The Archivist Magister is the head of the Library and is greedy to keep all the power. Neksa is the Archivist's assistant. The Curia consists of the heads of the major disciplines within the Library and complicit in all that he's done. Thomas Qualls is the Master of Cells, the Library's chief torturer. The Artifex Magnus, second in power, is in charge of manufacturing weapons and automatons. Captain Chu is an unworthy High Commander.
Serapeum are daughter libraries and are Library territory with their own laws, think "embassy". Hmmm, the Serapeum in Cadiz was designed by Gaudí. The widely respected Scholar Murasaki Shirasu is in charge in Cadiz. Fergus is the High Garda commander in Cadiz. Lieutenant Kali.
The Lighthouse is…
…headquarters for most of the Scholars. Scholar Parker is a Medica. Scholar Yang is not who they think.
The Feast of Greater Burning is a public execution of the Archivist's enemies.
The Iron Tower is…
…a prison for Obscurists, the magic users who make it possible for this world's tablets, the Blanks, to fill. The sadistic Gregory is the new Obscurist Magnus, third in power. Captain Nofret Alamsi is in charge of Tower security. The nasty Fratelli is the Master Copyist. Gregory intends for Benjamin Argent to breed with Morgan. The Black Archives had been a storehouse for forbidden knowledge.
Annis is the least-talented Obscurist and set to watch Morgan. She is known for her lovemaking, and Pyotr and Bjorn, who loves to play music, are some of her lovers. Friedrich and Millicent Thorpe are servants in the Tower. Natasha works with the Codex monitoring script.
Obscurist Magnus Keria Morning had been Magnus previous to Gregory. Obscurist Eskander has lived as a hermit in the Iron Tower for the past 40 years. They are Wolfe's parents.
The Garda are…
…divided into the Elite, fanatics who protect only one man, and the High, like Jess, who protect the Library and its sister Libraries throughout the world. Lieutenant Zara Cole had been under Santi. Lieutenant Tom "Troll" Rolleson had been in charge of the Blue Dogs and a friend of Jess' as was Centurion Botha.
The Enemy
Burners are rebels all over the world who believe that books, real books, should be available to anyone. That they should be able to own books for a personal library.
Smugglers supply real books to anyone who can pay. Callum Brightwell is Jess' and Brendan's grasping father, a smuggler of books who is based in London.
Red Ibrahim is one of the biggest, most notorious book smugglers — his public business is in shipping and storage — and is based in Alexandria. The fourteen-year-old Anit is his daughter and his heir, sailing back to Alexandria in the Valiant Isis with Santi, Khalila, Dario, and Glain her prisoners. Red Ibrahim's lieutenants include Tadalesh.
Elisinore Quest is a skilled Mesmer (hypnotist).
The Treaty of Pergamum is the foundational document that ensured the Great Library's neutrality. Until now, as Spain, Wales, England, Portugal, Turkey, Russia, Japan, the exiled queen of France, and the United Colonies of America have all pulled out. Codexes are like the Internet, passing news back and forth. The Translation Chambers are similar to a Star Trek-style transporter.
The Cover and Title
The cover is a broken library wall that's taken out the top edges of a shelf of ancient books, but that too is only a cover for what the Great Library is hiding in their black corruption. The hole itself is jagged but for the top edge, a silhouette of sphinxes facing each other, tails swishing. A pair of info blurbs are at the top in a pale yellow with the author's name directly below it in an embossed white in a gothic-style font. The title is inside the black hole with much fancier initial caps in an aged gradient of golden brown to vintage yellow. A smaller slash below that reveals the series information.
The title is metaphorical with the "smoke" of Jess' charade and the "iron" being Morgan's part in Smoke and Iron.
alapinski's review against another edition
5.0
Wow I'm glad I didn't give up on this series, but COME ON it just has to end eventually right? Right? Anyways, other than the fact that #5 is still coming, this one was amazing, loved the POV's and the action.
jdromsky's review against another edition
adventurous
hopeful
inspiring
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
4.5
The Great Library series has become one of my favorite!! I love everything about the characters and how they grow and face challenges both together and as individuals.
I was so happy forKalilah and Dario!! They’re engaged!
I was so happy for
kamattis's review
adventurous
dark
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.5
amybraunauthor's review against another edition
5.0
Man oh man, this was another great addition to the series! With the group now split up, there are four very different perspectives and storylines that are followed: Jess, Kahlila, Wolfe, and Morgan. All of them are very strong in their own right and I have a hard time pinning down who had my favourite storyline, though Wolfe's was mainly an emotional gateway to his damaged psyche. There were a lot of inventive twists and drama and conspiracies, all of it leading to a truly epic showdown and a powerful finale that has me craving the final book. There were new and very important characters (and side characters you just love, aka Annis), and while every character grew, I felt that Morgan and Kahlila gained the most development as they continued to rise in power and become stronger women. There is plenty of romance, but nobody can beat the eternal love between Santi and Wolfe. I'm honestly super excited to see where how this series concludes now that the final lines have been drawn and the stage is set for the last battle. Our heroes have scraped past death multiple times, but I get the sense they may not escape it next time... but I'm going to read the final book and cross my fingers in hopes that they do!
blckrorygilmore's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
emotional
reflective
sad
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.25
On my way to talk to my therapist!!!
terryt78's review
adventurous
mysterious
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
books4susie's review against another edition
4.0
Finally, all of our beloved characters begin to converge on Alexandria to take down the Archivist and restore the Great Library to its former mission. Told from several points of view, readers will be both captivated and heartbroken by where the storyline goes.