Scan barcode
seifknits's review against another edition
4.0
Some thoughts here about this book and how it is a great companion book to Their Skeletons Speak by Sally M. Walker: http://crossreferencing.wordpress.com/2012/10/01/cardiff-giant-vs-kennewick-man/
couillac's review against another edition
3.0
Having grown up in a circus town, I'm probably interested in the history of sideshow entertainment more than most. I remember seeing photos and a replica of the Cardiff Giant at Circus World Museum, but I never understood the story until now. Murphy starts it off brilliantly by presenting one presentation of the giant's story, then cycling back to reveal the great deception that had occurred behind the scenes. It's a fascinating glimpse into not just the early years of entertainment, but advertising, journalism, and even scientific history as well. A fun read.
thisfoxreads's review against another edition
3.0
I love Murphy's historical nonfiction books and always scoop them up for my library. I was disappointed with this one, however. It felt rushed--not a lot of photos of The Cardiff Giant (even though Murphy saw it as a part of his research), and not many illustrations in general--or the ones in the book were sometimes superfluous (Joseph Smith being tarred & feathered).
I appreciate that Murphy shared the story of a great American humbug, but I wish his usual polish had been applied to this book. Still, worth a read!
I appreciate that Murphy shared the story of a great American humbug, but I wish his usual polish had been applied to this book. Still, worth a read!
maidmarianlib's review against another edition
4.0
Well paced story with thoughtful connections to other history. Text is well done, although some of the illustrations don't feel as well chosen.
howifeelaboutbooks's review against another edition
3.0
Read for my children’s lit course, thankfully, because I never would have found it on my own but really enjoyed it. I’ve always loved hoaxes and conspiracy theories, and this book addresses the 1869 discovery of a petrified man. The last section adds a lot of interest regarding other hoaxes and conspiracy theories, as well as how and why the author researched the book. Check out my in-depth review at How I Feel About Books.
More...