Reviews

Alternate Oscars by Danny Peary

domesticat's review

Go to review page

4.0

If you've ever contended that the Oscars were a political piece of crap, or if the Academy was incapable of recognizing a truly stellar performance without twenty years of hindsight, this is a book to look into. It provides some interesting suggestions on movies that were probably more influential (Citizen Kane, etc.) than the actual winners (How Green Was My Valley) were.

Worth keeping around if you're a serious movie buff, but doesn't really have a lot of repeat-read value. Once absorbed, there is no more great subtext to get. Factoids are factoids.

gengelcox's review

Go to review page

3.0

This provides a good history of film through the years in excellent page-long essays, as well as catching the reader up on the critical classics of the medium.
More...