Reviews

Loving Aidan by Ashavan Doyon

shannon_cocktailsandbooks's review against another edition

3.0

Kenna's Thoughts

I'm just going to say, right off the back, that "Loving Aidan" is an extremely well written book with strong attention to detail that will immerse you into the story.  In fact, it sucks you in...and sucks you under...and doesn't let go until the final sentence.  Ashavan Doyon is gifted with the written world.

A little rundown here.  Aidan is a gay college student who is in love with his straight roommate.  They're friends, but it really hurts him that Sammy is bring woman after woman to their room for sex, while he as to spend all night in the all night diner down the street doing his classwork on his laptop.  Meanwhile, a teammate of Sammy's, Steven, takes an interest in Aidan.  It begins with teasing (because for all intents and purposes, Steven is straight as well, even dating a good friend of Aidan's), but eventually moves into a full fledged relationship.  Steven knows that Aidan loves Sammy, and is even ok with it.  That is my first problem with the story.  Steven tells Aidan that, if the chance to be with Sammy pops up for him, then he should take that chance, even though it would break his heart.  WHAT??  No way, Jose!  If you're with me, you're with me.  Especially if I'm in love with you!

Eventually, the chance DOES present itself.  Sammy is suddenly very jealous of Steven, and after witnessing (unbeknownst to Aiden and Steven) an intimate moment, goes caveman and declares that Aiden should be HIS...even though he's got a crazy and insanely jealous b***h of a girlfriend.  He says that he wants to break up with said b***h and be with Aidan, and that he MUST break it off completely with Steven, which Aidan does.  Ok, by this time, I'm hating every single character in the story but poor Steven.  Poor, sensitive, deeply in love Steven.  I'm pretty sure you're not supposed to hate the "hero" of the story, and I was getting very upset.  It all felt like cheating to me, and I was literally sweating as I read, and I had to keep taking breaks because I was ANGRY.  There were several times where I just wanted to put it down and walk away, but I had committed to reading it and reviewing it, I pressed on. I had read several reviews from other people, and there were complaints about there being too much sex.  Well, there is a LOT of sex here.  I enjoy plentiful sex scenes in my books, and I have to say, every single one of these were extremely hot.  I didn't consider them to be too much, but I can see where someone else would.  To each his own there.  I just really dig the sex ;-)

Underneath the love triangle, there is a separate story.  On campus, there is a very anti-gay movement.  There is violence, and it lands Aidan's ex in the hospital in serious condition.  Aidan and Steven have to endure it, but THEY could at least fight back.  Also, there are some pretty mean sorority girls who are pretty pissed off about their boyfriends dumping them for Aidan, and they enlist the help of their fellow sisters and THEIR boyfriends...mostly from the football team.  More violence ensues putting Sammy and Aidan in the hospital as well.  This story could be a book unto itself, and I think it would be a great one.  It's timely.  It's interesting.  It's real, and it's worth reading.  I would have been pretty happy with that if I didn't have the love triangle distracting me...and frustrating me.

I won't give away the ending.  In fact, I think I said too much already.  I just wanted to make sure that you get the full idea of what goes on in the book.  I'm not going to tell you that you shouldn't read it, simply because it upset me.  As I said in the first paragraph, "Loving Aidan" is beautifully written.  The characters are well developed, and the story flows.  I actually wish I could give two reviews...one for writing style and one for the story.  Personal tastes are personal tastes.  If you're angst is your thing, you'll absolutely LOVE this. if you're into heartwrenching love triangles, this is the book for you. If you like very steamy (actually nuclear) male/male sex scenes you'll get a charge out of it.    Unfortunately, even all that amazing sex couldn't make me like this book enough to go above three stars.
This review was originally posted on Cocktails and Books.

the_novel_approach's review

4.0

This book pushed my sense of right and wrong, but I feel the author wrote a very honest story of college-aged angst. As bad as I felt for Steven, Aidan made the right choice and everything works out in the end. The heat meter of this book is off the charts, but there is so much emotion when they make love that there is no doubt of the feelings the men share.

I highly recommend this book, but beware it isn’t all sunshine and roses. However, there is a wonderful HEA.

You can read the rest of Jackie's review at The Novel Approach