Scan barcode
austinbeeman's review against another edition
4.0
Nebula Awards Showcase 2015
RATED 80% POSITIVE. STORY SCORE = 3.87 OUT OF 5
13 STORIES : 4 GREAT / 5 GOOD / 2 AVERAGE / 2 POOR / 0 DNF
An solid respectable anthology that presents the Nebula Award nominees and winners in a clear and bright light, letting them speak for themselves. Every nominee for Short Story and Novelette is included as well as the winner of Novella category, excerpts from winning novels, poems, articles, and one reprint from the newly minted Grand Master Samuel R Delaney. I have only considered the complete stories in this anthology for rating and review, but I do recommend reading the entire volume.
The Nebula Awards are given by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA). This anthology, while called Showcase 2015, includes stories originally published in 2013.
My top selections from among these Nebula Nominees:
If You Were a Dinosaur, My Love • (2013) • short story by Rachel Swirsky.
Not truly Science Fiction or Fantasy, this incredible short story embraces the language of both in a bittersweet love vignette. To reveal too much would be to spoil the surprise, but this is quite powerful.
Alive, Alive Oh • (2013) • short story by Sylvia Spruck Wrigley.
A tragic tale of motherhood stranded on a planet that was only supposed to be a temporary mission. This one slowly walks forward the rational outcome of its premise to the painful conclusion.
The Waiting Stars • (2013) • novelette by Aliette de Bodard.
Two stories told in alternating segments. Two women explore a derelict Mind Ship to recover what is left of their family member. On another planet, two girls have been rescued from ‘fate-worse-than-death’ but at the cost of any connection to their memories or culture. This is space opera and human drama with complex multi-layered characters as well being great space opera.
In Joy, Knowing the Abyss Behind • (2013) • novelette by Sarah Pinsker.
This is haunting. An architect on his deathbed with one last design to draw. Memories of a secret he designed years ago. The pain of family secrets and mystery of their discovery. I didn’t go to a Great rating when in read this in Sarah Pinsker’s Collection, but I love this even more now.
***
NEBULA AWARDS SHOWCASE 2015 IS RATED 80% POSITIVE
13 STORIES : 4 GREAT / 5 GOOD / 2 AVERAGE / 2 POOR / 0 DNF
If You Were a Dinosaur, My Love • (2013) • short story by Rachel Swirsky
Great. While not truly Science Fiction or Fantasy, this incredible short story embraces the language of both in a bittersweet love vignette.
The Sounds of Old Earth • (2013) • short story by Matthew Kressel
Good. As everyone is escaping a dying earth for space colonies, one man lingers with his ducks.
Selkie Stories Are for Losers • short fiction by Sofia Samatar [as by Sophia Samatar]
Average. Longing and various stories about selfies discovering their fur coats.
Selected Program Notes from the Retrospective Exhibition of Theresa Rosenberg Latimer • (2013) • short fiction by Kenneth Schneyer
Good. A haunting masterpiece of fantasy(?) experimentally told through program notes of artwork created by one woman over a lifetime.
Alive, Alive Oh • (2013) • short story by Sylvia Spruck Wrigley
Great. A tragic tale of motherhood stranded on a planet that was only supposed to be a temporary mission.
The Waiting Stars • (2013) • novelette by Aliette de Bodard
Great. Two stories told in alternating segments. Two women explore a derelict Mind Ship to recover what is left of their family member. On another planet, two girls have been rescued from ‘fate-worse-than-death’ but at the cost of any connection to their memories or culture.
Paranormal Romance • (2013) • novelette by Christopher Barzak
Poor. One dimensional characters, a love-witch and a werewolf- go on a bad first date. Pedestrian.
They Shall Salt the Earth with Seeds of Glass • (2013) • novelette by Alaya Dawn Johnson
Average. Two sisters from a rural farming community that is oppressed by the Glassine must travel to the city to try to get an abortion.
Pearl Rehabilitative Colony for Ungrateful Daughters • (2013) • novelette by Henry Lien
Good. A fun fantasy adventure of ‘mean-girls’ who compete while training in a figure skating martial art.
In Joy, Knowing the Abyss Behind • (2013) • novelette by Sarah Pinsker
Great. This is haunting. An architect on his deathbed with one last design to draw. Memories of a secret he designed years ago. The pain of family secrets and mystery of their discovery.
The Litigation Master and the Monkey King • (2013) • novelette by Ken Liu
Poor. A Chinese lawyer (and a mystical Monkey King ?!!?) decides to do the right thing at the cost of his life.
The Weight of the Sunrise • (2013) • novella by Vylar Kaftan
Good. In an Alternate History Incan Empire where smallpox was contained, a man is brought to the King to translate a negotiation with Americans over a vaccine.
Time Considered as a Helix of Semi-Precious Stones • (1968) • novelette by Samuel R. Delany
Good. A wild ride as a small time crook works his way up through a series of interactions and parties. Pretty groovy 1960s style.
RATED 80% POSITIVE. STORY SCORE = 3.87 OUT OF 5
13 STORIES : 4 GREAT / 5 GOOD / 2 AVERAGE / 2 POOR / 0 DNF
An solid respectable anthology that presents the Nebula Award nominees and winners in a clear and bright light, letting them speak for themselves. Every nominee for Short Story and Novelette is included as well as the winner of Novella category, excerpts from winning novels, poems, articles, and one reprint from the newly minted Grand Master Samuel R Delaney. I have only considered the complete stories in this anthology for rating and review, but I do recommend reading the entire volume.
The Nebula Awards are given by the Science Fiction and Fantasy Writers of America (SFWA). This anthology, while called Showcase 2015, includes stories originally published in 2013.
My top selections from among these Nebula Nominees:
If You Were a Dinosaur, My Love • (2013) • short story by Rachel Swirsky.
Not truly Science Fiction or Fantasy, this incredible short story embraces the language of both in a bittersweet love vignette. To reveal too much would be to spoil the surprise, but this is quite powerful.
Alive, Alive Oh • (2013) • short story by Sylvia Spruck Wrigley.
A tragic tale of motherhood stranded on a planet that was only supposed to be a temporary mission. This one slowly walks forward the rational outcome of its premise to the painful conclusion.
The Waiting Stars • (2013) • novelette by Aliette de Bodard.
Two stories told in alternating segments. Two women explore a derelict Mind Ship to recover what is left of their family member. On another planet, two girls have been rescued from ‘fate-worse-than-death’ but at the cost of any connection to their memories or culture. This is space opera and human drama with complex multi-layered characters as well being great space opera.
In Joy, Knowing the Abyss Behind • (2013) • novelette by Sarah Pinsker.
This is haunting. An architect on his deathbed with one last design to draw. Memories of a secret he designed years ago. The pain of family secrets and mystery of their discovery. I didn’t go to a Great rating when in read this in Sarah Pinsker’s Collection, but I love this even more now.
***
NEBULA AWARDS SHOWCASE 2015 IS RATED 80% POSITIVE
13 STORIES : 4 GREAT / 5 GOOD / 2 AVERAGE / 2 POOR / 0 DNF
If You Were a Dinosaur, My Love • (2013) • short story by Rachel Swirsky
Great. While not truly Science Fiction or Fantasy, this incredible short story embraces the language of both in a bittersweet love vignette.
The Sounds of Old Earth • (2013) • short story by Matthew Kressel
Good. As everyone is escaping a dying earth for space colonies, one man lingers with his ducks.
Selkie Stories Are for Losers • short fiction by Sofia Samatar [as by Sophia Samatar]
Average. Longing and various stories about selfies discovering their fur coats.
Selected Program Notes from the Retrospective Exhibition of Theresa Rosenberg Latimer • (2013) • short fiction by Kenneth Schneyer
Good. A haunting masterpiece of fantasy(?) experimentally told through program notes of artwork created by one woman over a lifetime.
Alive, Alive Oh • (2013) • short story by Sylvia Spruck Wrigley
Great. A tragic tale of motherhood stranded on a planet that was only supposed to be a temporary mission.
The Waiting Stars • (2013) • novelette by Aliette de Bodard
Great. Two stories told in alternating segments. Two women explore a derelict Mind Ship to recover what is left of their family member. On another planet, two girls have been rescued from ‘fate-worse-than-death’ but at the cost of any connection to their memories or culture.
Paranormal Romance • (2013) • novelette by Christopher Barzak
Poor. One dimensional characters, a love-witch and a werewolf- go on a bad first date. Pedestrian.
They Shall Salt the Earth with Seeds of Glass • (2013) • novelette by Alaya Dawn Johnson
Average. Two sisters from a rural farming community that is oppressed by the Glassine must travel to the city to try to get an abortion.
Pearl Rehabilitative Colony for Ungrateful Daughters • (2013) • novelette by Henry Lien
Good. A fun fantasy adventure of ‘mean-girls’ who compete while training in a figure skating martial art.
In Joy, Knowing the Abyss Behind • (2013) • novelette by Sarah Pinsker
Great. This is haunting. An architect on his deathbed with one last design to draw. Memories of a secret he designed years ago. The pain of family secrets and mystery of their discovery.
The Litigation Master and the Monkey King • (2013) • novelette by Ken Liu
Poor. A Chinese lawyer (and a mystical Monkey King ?!!?) decides to do the right thing at the cost of his life.
The Weight of the Sunrise • (2013) • novella by Vylar Kaftan
Good. In an Alternate History Incan Empire where smallpox was contained, a man is brought to the King to translate a negotiation with Americans over a vaccine.
Time Considered as a Helix of Semi-Precious Stones • (1968) • novelette by Samuel R. Delany
Good. A wild ride as a small time crook works his way up through a series of interactions and parties. Pretty groovy 1960s style.
randalm's review against another edition
3.0
It's hard to rate such a disparate collection. I will say that I was pleasantly surprised to find how LGBTQ-inclusive many of the stories were. Here's a quick rundown from strongest to weakest, in my humble opinion:
“Time considered as a helix of semi-precious stones” – I adore Samuel R. Delany’s vision. This piece left me longing (in a good way) for more about the Singers in his story.
“The waiting stars” – This was an intriguing novella, both innovative and relatable. I’m going to seek out more of Aliette de Bodard’s Xuya universe.
“The weight of the sunrise” – I thoroughly enjoyed Vylar Kaftan’s alternative history tale, which speculates what would have happened if the Incan civilization had survived small pox.
“Alive, alive oh” – A somber, beautifully told short story.
excerpt from “Sister Mine” – The writing was a bit overly conversational in tone for my taste, but I liked it enough to want to check out Nalo Hopkinson’s full novel.
“The Sounds of Old Earth” – Touching if a bit predictable. Good writing.
“They shall salt the earth with seeds of glass” – I was drawn into this story of alien occupation of Earth but found details of the backstory to be lacking.
“Pearl Rehabilitative Colony for Ungrateful Daughters” –Hysterical. Mean girls in outer space.
“The litigation master and the monkey king” Well written and kept me engaged. But I’m not sure how this is sci-fi or fantasy.
“Selected program notes from the retrospective exhibition of Theresa Rosenberg Latimer” – An innovative approach to storytelling, although it felt a touch thin.
“Selkie stories are for losers” – A moderately satisfying story of longing.
“Paranormal romance” – Cute urban fantasy story.
“In joy, knowing the abyss behind” – Overly sentimental.
excert from “Ancillary Justice” – This was too short to give me a sense of the larger tale.
“If you were a dinosaur, my love” – I’m not sure why this was the winner.
“Time considered as a helix of semi-precious stones” – I adore Samuel R. Delany’s vision. This piece left me longing (in a good way) for more about the Singers in his story.
“The waiting stars” – This was an intriguing novella, both innovative and relatable. I’m going to seek out more of Aliette de Bodard’s Xuya universe.
“The weight of the sunrise” – I thoroughly enjoyed Vylar Kaftan’s alternative history tale, which speculates what would have happened if the Incan civilization had survived small pox.
“Alive, alive oh” – A somber, beautifully told short story.
excerpt from “Sister Mine” – The writing was a bit overly conversational in tone for my taste, but I liked it enough to want to check out Nalo Hopkinson’s full novel.
“The Sounds of Old Earth” – Touching if a bit predictable. Good writing.
“They shall salt the earth with seeds of glass” – I was drawn into this story of alien occupation of Earth but found details of the backstory to be lacking.
“Pearl Rehabilitative Colony for Ungrateful Daughters” –Hysterical. Mean girls in outer space.
“The litigation master and the monkey king” Well written and kept me engaged. But I’m not sure how this is sci-fi or fantasy.
“Selected program notes from the retrospective exhibition of Theresa Rosenberg Latimer” – An innovative approach to storytelling, although it felt a touch thin.
“Selkie stories are for losers” – A moderately satisfying story of longing.
“Paranormal romance” – Cute urban fantasy story.
“In joy, knowing the abyss behind” – Overly sentimental.
excert from “Ancillary Justice” – This was too short to give me a sense of the larger tale.
“If you were a dinosaur, my love” – I’m not sure why this was the winner.
memoriast's review against another edition
Personal favourites:
- “Alive, Alive Oh” by Sylvia Spruck Wrigley
- "The Waiting Stars" by Aliette de Bodard
- “The Weight of the Sunrise” by Vylar Kaftan
Other highlights:
- "The Sounds of Old Earth" by Matthew Kressel
- "Selkie Stories Are for Losers" by Sofia Samatar
- “Selected Program Notes from the Retrospective Exhibition of Theresa Rosenberg Latimer” by Kenneth Schneyer
- “If You Were a Dinosaur, My Love” by Rachel Swirsky
- “In Joy, Knowing the Abyss Behind” by Sarah Pinsker
jameseckman's review
2.0
Most of the stories are very sad and downbeat, Atwood fans would enjoy them. The one upbeat romantic comedy is so fantasy light that a simple cut and paste would remove all fantasy elements. There are a couple of good stories, but one I'd already read. Not much bang for the buck.
bookwyrmknits's review
4.0
I didn't read most of the stories, only the winners and one or two others. However, the ones that I read I enjoyed.
I read:
"The Waiting Stars" by Aliette de Bodard
"The Weight of the Sunrise" by Vylar Kaftan
"If You Were a Dinosaur, My Love" by Rachel Swirsky
"Time Considered as a Helix of Semi-Precious Stones" by Samuel R. Delany
I read:
"The Waiting Stars" by Aliette de Bodard
"The Weight of the Sunrise" by Vylar Kaftan
"If You Were a Dinosaur, My Love" by Rachel Swirsky
"Time Considered as a Helix of Semi-Precious Stones" by Samuel R. Delany
More...