Scan barcode
ladydamonayde's review
5.0
This was a great book. I actually met JL at MidSouthCon this past weekend and really loved talking to her. She actually warned me about the twist at the end, but I still didn't see it comming.
I've been looking for more great steampunk and I've definetly found it in this book. I hope the next one comes out soon. I'll be keeping a close eye out.
I've been looking for more great steampunk and I've definetly found it in this book. I hope the next one comes out soon. I'll be keeping a close eye out.
r_j_setser's review against another edition
3.0
The Boxcar Baby is a steampunk adventure with a touch of fantasy that will tug at your heart strings.
AB’Gale is a sweet but fiery character who desperately wants to find her adopted father. Everything in her normal life is ripped apart when he goes missing and it’s up to her to find him and put it back together.
This book took me a while to get into. I wasn’t taken with the writing style right off (it desperately needs an editor….), and a lot of the story confused me in the first several chapters. But as it picked up, I started to like Abby much more and the story became easier to follow; that is, until it turned fantasy.
I really enjoy fantasy don’t get me wrong, but during the first three quarters of the book, the story world felt like a steampunk/ Dystopian tale. With nothing to give me the idea that it was actually fantasy. Then all the sudden, one character asks another if she believes in vampires and werewolves and everything gets very weird from there. I wouldn’t have been taken so off guard if maybe a legend or scary story of some fantasy creature had been told at the beginning of the book, but as it is, it seemed to completely change genres suddenly. I feel like the author was going for the element of surprise, but I think there is such thing as too much surprise!
I adore the characters though! And the storyline itself is very intriguing. There is a lot of action, mystery, problem solving, and who doesn’t love a mysterious map to follow? And looking back at the story, I really feel like I enjoyed it after the initial shock of genre changing, so I’m very likely to finish the series.
It does have some mild cursing, several mentions of brothels as well as Abby herself explaining to younger girls what a brothel is, encounters with men who attempt to “have their way” with the young girls (not succeeding), and the action is shocking and borderline gory, though I didn’t think it crossed the line into horror. I definitely recommend it for older teens even though our main character is only 15, because of its dark themes.
Overall, I’m inclined to give The Boxcar Baby 3 stars out of 5, though now I know what to expect out of the story, the rest of the series may receive a higher rating.
I received this book from the author via TCM Blog Tours for the purpose of this review. All comments and opinions are entirely my own.
This is a LiteratureApproved.com Review
AB’Gale is a sweet but fiery character who desperately wants to find her adopted father. Everything in her normal life is ripped apart when he goes missing and it’s up to her to find him and put it back together.
This book took me a while to get into. I wasn’t taken with the writing style right off (it desperately needs an editor….), and a lot of the story confused me in the first several chapters. But as it picked up, I started to like Abby much more and the story became easier to follow; that is, until it turned fantasy.
I really enjoy fantasy don’t get me wrong, but during the first three quarters of the book, the story world felt like a steampunk/ Dystopian tale. With nothing to give me the idea that it was actually fantasy. Then all the sudden, one character asks another if she believes in vampires and werewolves and everything gets very weird from there. I wouldn’t have been taken so off guard if maybe a legend or scary story of some fantasy creature had been told at the beginning of the book, but as it is, it seemed to completely change genres suddenly. I feel like the author was going for the element of surprise, but I think there is such thing as too much surprise!
I adore the characters though! And the storyline itself is very intriguing. There is a lot of action, mystery, problem solving, and who doesn’t love a mysterious map to follow? And looking back at the story, I really feel like I enjoyed it after the initial shock of genre changing, so I’m very likely to finish the series.
It does have some mild cursing, several mentions of brothels as well as Abby herself explaining to younger girls what a brothel is, encounters with men who attempt to “have their way” with the young girls (not succeeding), and the action is shocking and borderline gory, though I didn’t think it crossed the line into horror. I definitely recommend it for older teens even though our main character is only 15, because of its dark themes.
Overall, I’m inclined to give The Boxcar Baby 3 stars out of 5, though now I know what to expect out of the story, the rest of the series may receive a higher rating.
I received this book from the author via TCM Blog Tours for the purpose of this review. All comments and opinions are entirely my own.
This is a LiteratureApproved.com Review
More...