Reviews

Thumped by Megan McCafferty

outoftheblue14's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Here it is, the much anticipated sequel to Bumped. I couldn't wait to read it when I learned it was coming out!

It's been 35 weeks since Megan and Harmony separated, and now they're famous, because they're both pregnant with twins, and about to deliver on the same date!

Harmony has returned to Goodside and settled in married life with Ram, trying to fit back into her community. Her people, however, seem to distrust her, and she can't stop thinking about Jondoe. On the other hand, Melody is very busy appearing everywhere with Jondoe, with whom she supposedly fell helplessly in love, and bringing forth her brand. Zen has had a growth spurth and offers to become pro, which he won't accept. Also, Ventura Vida, Melody's long-time rival, keeps hitting on him, making Melody jealous.

While their adoring fans can't wait for the "Double Double Due Date", the day when Melody and Harmony are supposed to give birth, the two girls need to decide how they can solve the mess they got into, and the only way might be finally telling the truth.

All reviews for Thumped point out that this book is so much better than the first one. I agree, it really is better. I think it's mainly because once you get to the second book, you already know the world and the slang, so it's easier to understand what's happening (while at the beginning of Bumped you feel a bit disoriented). There's also a lot more action here than in the previous book, and things happen quickly. Megan McCafferty doesn't waste pages at the beginning to retell what happened before, so it's a good thing to read this book straight after the first.

The ending was very appropriate, although bittersweet. I loved the last scene with Melody and Zen. Zen has been my favourite character in the series. He's funny, sweet, and opinionated. But I also loved Megan for standing up to him and declaring she doesn't want to be the spokeswoman for the right to use condoms. I also loved it that he finally got tall (handsome, he already was). Too bad Melody can't have his babies.

I'd recommend this book (well, the whole series) to lovers of chick-lit who are looking for something with a little more substance. The dystopian element doesn't play a big part in the series, so you can read this even if you're not afan of the genre. (And no, I didn't know what the title meant. After reading the book, I had to resort to UrbanDictionary.com)

Cover attraction: pretty and delicate. It suggests the idea of birth. I love the baby blue background.

jennrocca's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

It was what I expected the sequel to Bumped to be. I still think it felt shallow but the story tied up nicely and, again, I didn't know how it would turn out so it stayed a page turner for me. I like the message even if the story itself could run a little sappy at times.

I'm really glad it's not a trilogy. The story is done and doesn't need more telling.

myriadreads's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

In Thumped, most women in the U.S. are sterile by age 18 due to a virus. Teen girls become powerful players in the "pregging" biz, and all of the branding power that a commercialized nation can summon is bent to the cause of convincing teens to pregg their eggs, pronto.

shhchar's review against another edition

Go to review page

1.0

I wasn't very impressed with the first book, but I did like it. I'm not sure where Thumped went so wrong. The characters were unappealing, and I predicted the ending many pages in advance.

Harmony was just as naive as she was in the first book, just more delusional. Jondoe (which is a ridiculous name, I might add) annoyed me with his delusions as well. Zen and Melody, my favorites in the first book, seemed as if they were completely different characters in this book. Their relationship troubles only irked me, they didn't make me concerned for their wellbeings. The additional character twist/plot of Ventura seemed too unexplored to even be mentioned.

I could go into more detail, and more things I considered irrelevant and poorly dealt with (cough birthmother cough) but I'll just leave this review as is. If you liked the first novel, you'll like the second. If you were on the fence with the first one, I don't recommend the second.

mandey1's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I liked this one better than the first, but still not a favorite.

this_fishy_reads's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

Reading this was such a chore.

The only reason I picked up Bumped and Thumped was because I loved McCafferty's Jessica Darling series when I was a teenager. But the writing in these two books is so forced and stilted that I'm afraid to go back and find out Jess actually sucked the big one.

The themes here are totally commendable, too--the commercialization of sex, the sexualization of kids--but their handling is so freaking heavy-handed. McCafferty rushed through the ending like even she didn't want to be there.

sarahanne8382's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

I liked this sequel to Bumped just a little bit more than the story it follows (and you must read Bumped in order to appreciate Thumped. While in the first one I had trouble getting into the satirical tone, this time I knew what to expect, and as events unfold, this one has quite a bit of heart.

In Bumped we left sisters Melody and Harmony shortly after Harmony slept with the guy Melody was paid to be impregnated by. Harmony's adventure with Jondoe only began to give us an idea of her personality and this time around we finally get to understand her more fully.

The action in Thumped starts up 35 weeks later as both girls are approaching their identical due dates with twin girls. Melody returned to Goodside shortly after bumping with Jondoe, but is now stifling under their strict control and needs to be with her sister as their deliveries approach. Most of the book follows her emotional journey to be free of the strict rules she grew up under as she strives for the opportunity to make her own life choices. The other main characters in the book, including Melody, have a similar break from oppression as they all learn how to make their own decisions about what they will do with their lives and who they will do it with.

I still found myself chuckling at several points in this book and the satirical setting definitely carries over from the first book, but McCafferty also makes some serious points here. When it's time for the girls to actually deliver, the control the government has over the whole process is frightening. As someone who not that long ago delivered a baby it was scary enough trusting the care of myself and my baby to doctors and nurses I trusted to follow my wishes, but watching the girls in this book basically not be given a choice about how they will deliver, whether or not they'll have drugs, whether or not they'll be able to breastfeed, made me scared to get anywhere near one of their hospitals if I was even thinking about becoming pregnant. Also the way the hysteria of adults not being able to become parents is used as an excuse to control the reproductive abilities of teenage girls is pretty disgusting. And yet all of this being told how you can and can't protect yourself from unwanted pregnancy feels eerily familiar.

In the end McCafferty's characters find their way, and this series that initially had me laughing uncomfortably ended up making me cry because there were just so many feelings to be had at the end of it all.

If you made it through Bumped and are dying to know what happened to Melody and Harmony, then you must read Thumped, but realize that you'll be getting much more of an emotional punch this time around.

jenlynnhill's review against another edition

Go to review page

2.0

I didn't really care for this book, I felt like it didn't answer all the questions raised in the first book, and that the author was trying to wrap up all of the loose ends. I think it would have been more successful as a trilogy, if the story was fleshed out a little more.

leilakrzyzewski's review against another edition

Go to review page

3.0

This book is rilly preggy. Like totally humpy.

90sinmyheart's review against another edition

Go to review page

4.0

Fantastic, although I fear what the third book, if it is to be written, will be called h(umped)