Reviews

Everything, Everything by Nicola Yoon

trin's review

Go to review page

4.0

Nicola Yoon's Everything, Everything is the kind of book that feels effortless -- which is in fact one of the surest signs of a controlled, skillful piece of writing. But you don't think about any of that while you're reading it because you're so deeply immersed in the world of Yoon's protagonist, Madeline. Her world is small -- she has a rare immunodeficiency disorder, which means she can't leave her environmentally controlled house -- but as a character she's vast. Her voice leaps vibrantly off the page -- almost instantly, you feel like you've known her your whole life. Yoon uses IMs and diagrams and illustrations to great effect, and the story moves at a breathless pace, incorporating an endearing romance and a fitting twist. Like The Fault in Our Stars' Hazel, Madeline is the perfect anchor. She's the type of heroine YA literature deserves.

oscarreads's review

Go to review page

2.0

Okay can someone recommend me some books I might actually like cause 4 two star books in a row is enough

aliceewertsson's review

Go to review page

3.0

Really liked it, an easy read.

molb8's review against another edition

Go to review page

5.0

Wow! It took me less than a day and a half to read this. It is amazing! A definite recommend and I couldn't put it down.

princzukos's review

Go to review page

3.0

I decided to read Everything, Everything because I thought it would be similar to The Fault in our Stars (which I still haven't read but I watched the movie), but less tragic. I mean, Maddy has a rare disease that makes her allergic to everything but she's attracted to Olly at first sight, so we can assume that they'll fall in love. Plus, they're love would be a little painful and angsty since they're teenagers and can't be within like 5 feet from each other, but they'd still find a way to work it out. And no one dies at the end, so it'll have a happy ending.
(This is sort of irrelevant but Olly is bald during the beginning of the book, so I thought he might've also have a disease/cancer. Just another similarity with TFIOS)

Anyways, their relationship is super cheesy, but I thought it was extremely cute because they're both eager to get to know more about each other disregarding her condition. Plus they're IMs, emails, and conversations are super dorky and random to a point where I squeal whenever they're mentioned.
(They're relationship later develops and becomes more intimate, but I won't spoil the good stuff.)

The only thing I didn't like about the book was that it's short and a quick-read (I seriously read all 300+ pages within a couple hours). Some chapters/pages are just doodles, and others are either 2-5 sentences long (kind of similar to Aristotle and Dante Discover the Secrets of the Universe). Also, I felt as if the focus of the book shifts too much. For example, the story is supposed to be centered around Maddy's disease and how it effects her love-life, but then at the end it centers around the mom's mental illness (BIGGEST PLOT TWIST I'VE EVER READ) and it just changes the point of everything!!

In conclusion, it's a pretty okay book. I enjoyed reading it and thought the illustrations were cute, but the plot twist at the end just ruined it for me. :/

carlisajc's review

Go to review page

4.0

*I was given an advanced copy of this novel to read and review by the publisher. This in no way affects my opinion of the book!*

Everything, Everything by Nicola Yoon was, well, everything that I’ve heard it was going to be. It was fast, fun, and unique. I read it in less than a day because I was taken in with the story of Olly and Madeline. And it’s beautifully written. Seriously, so beautiful.


So first let’s talk about Madeline. She’s an eighteen-year-old girl who hasn’t left her house in 17 years. Yep, you heard me right. She lives in her house, which is essentially a bubble with filters that completely refresh the air every couple of hours. People who come in–practically no one–had to be decontaminated and were forbidden to touch Madeline. Why, you may ask, are there so many precautions? Madeline has a disease called Sever Combined Immunodeficiency (SCID), making her allergic to basically anything and everything. She’s completely shut off from the outside world. She only interacts with her mother (who is also her primary physician) and her nurse Carla. Man, that would suck. But despite her hard life, Madeline is a great character. She’s smart and she reads all the time and she writes reviews on her blog online (I love her reviews a lot). Basically, she’s me if I had SCID.

But anyways, the book is written in first person in Madeline’s perspective. And I just love her. I want to best best friends with her. She’s had a hard life…or not much of a life at all, but she’s still optimistic. She still looks for the beauty in things. She still hopes for the best even though nothing in her life has lead her to believe “the best” is going to happen. And I just love that. And I love her.

Oh, one more thing about her. Diversity has become so important in YA fiction recently. People are pushing for more diverse characters and cultures represented in literature. Madeline is half-Japanese and half-black, which I find so interesting! But what I think I like the best about it is that it wasn’t just something thrown in there to add diversity. It was just who she is. It doesn’t change her. Her race doesn’t overrun her life. And it shouldn’t. It’s just who she is, and that’s wonderful.

Okay, moving on. So Madeline lives in her house and only in her house. One day she sees a new family moving in next door…and they see her, too, staring in the window. So a brother and sister come to the door with a bundt cake, hoping to meet Madeline and have her show them around. Her mother quickly sees them (and the bundt cake) out the door, in fear of contaminating Madeline. But Madeline learns the brother’s name: Oliver. He goes to his window and writes her a message and they start communicating that way: with glances and small, written messages. Until they get each other’s email addresses. And they start talking…and talking…and talking. And the rest is history (or, if you haven’t read it yet, the rest is the future? For a person who hasn’t read the book yet, has the story happened or is it in the future? Whoa. Just blew my mind a little bit).

One thing about this book is that I wish we would have gotten to know Oliver (she calls him Olly) a little better. Madeline is very visual and, since she’s always in her house she sees quite a lot out of her window. So we get a lot of glimpses and small moments of understanding. But I wanted to go deeper. I wanted to get to know him on the same level that I had gotten to know Madeline. What I did see, though…what I did learn about him…I loved. I loved his cute protectiveness of her. His desire to talk to her all the time, to learn everything about her. His willingness to actually work for the relationship and not to give up just because it seemed a little hard.

Also, there is kind of insta-love, but I think it’s totally realistic and understandable in Madeline’s case. Insta-love is kind of a big no-no in many book blogger and reviewer’s eyes…But for Madeline doesn’t it make sense? Wouldn’t it be realistic? She’s literally cut off from everything except her many, many books and movies and the internet. As a result, she’s basically a hopeless romantic (that’s what books do to you, believe me). And she’s had no interaction with people her age. So when an attractive boy moves next door and starts talking to her, it’s realistic that she’s instantly going to like him. That she’s instantly going to be thinking about the “what if’s?” that come with crushes and boys. So, yes, the situation is kind of “She sees him out the window and then can’t stop thinking about him,” but it makes sense to me in this situation. It didn’t seem fake or forced. But just wanted to throw that out there.

The writing in this book was beautifully poetic. Seriously, I was highlighting left and right, backwards and forwards. I wish I could share some quotes with you but I don’t think I’m supposed to since I didn’t read the finished copy. BUT IT’S SO BEAUTIFUL, TRUST ME. And when authors and narrators are almost poetic, I think it’s really easy for it to become forced and unrealistic (I ranted about it on a review here). But it didn’t seem like that here. Nicola Yoon writes beautifully. I need a synonym for beautifully, I’ve used it too much. Delightfully. Charmingly. Gorgeously. Gracefully. Wonderfully. Tastefully. Exquisitely. Thank you, Thesaurus.com. All of these adjectives work, well, beautifully. Eep.

Also this book is so fast. You could read it in less than a day if you wanted to. It’s 320 pages, but the chapters are so so so so short that it just flies by. Also many pages have illustrations or emails or some of her reviews on them. So it literally just goes by so fast. Which is both a blessing and a curse, if you think about it. It’s good because it never drags. You always want to keep going, keep reading their story. But then at the end, you’re just left sitting there, wanting more. Craving more. Needing more. This was my note upon finishing the last page: “WHAT I NEED MORE.” There you have it, straight from my exquisitely well-written note.

But I have mixed feelings about the ending. I can’t really say a lot without including spoilers, but I just wasn’t expecting what happened to happen. Which is kind of a good thing, right? It wasn’t predictable at all. Nope, did not see that one coming. But part of me also doesn’t find it believable. But part of me does. It’s like I’d almost have to overlook some things for it to sit well in my mind…What I learned in my last English class is called “the willing suspension of disbelief.” This is nothing major. Don’t not read this because of this note. Seriously, you still need to read it. But now I’m going to include spoilers. If you read this, it will spoil the entire ending for you, and kind of the entire book, so be warned:
SpoilerSo Madeline is not sick. She’s never been sick. Her dad and brother died in a car accident years ago, when she was still really young. And her mom kind of had a mental breakdown and lost it. And her mom’s a doctor…so she kind of diagnosed Madeline with SCID and over-protected her so she wouldn’t lose Madeline too. Her mom honestly believed Madeline had this disease…but this was just so unexpected. And to have something like this, to always be home-schooled and need constant attention…wouldn’t there be someone who questioned her mom? Like Carla, the nurse. As soon as Madeline said something to her, Carla was like “Yes…I never thought your mom got over your dad and brother. Something’s not right.” Wouldn’t she have thought that before and done something about it? I don’t know.


THE CONSENSUS
READ THIS BOOK. It’s so fast that you can’t even say you don’t have time for it. And it’s just cute and wonderful and beautiful. And with a plot and story that I’ve never seen before.

sarahwarrz64's review against another edition

Go to review page

mysterious fast-paced

4.0

dibajida's review against another edition

Go to review page

adventurous challenging emotional funny hopeful inspiring lighthearted mysterious reflective sad tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? A mix
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? No

4.5

loved the voices and dual narration. ending went a different route but nonetheless I enjoyed it. 

emilythill's review

Go to review page

emotional hopeful inspiring sad tense medium-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? It's complicated
  • Loveable characters? It's complicated
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

3.5

niya_books's review

Go to review page

emotional hopeful inspiring lighthearted sad fast-paced
  • Plot- or character-driven? Character
  • Strong character development? Yes
  • Loveable characters? Yes
  • Diverse cast of characters? Yes
  • Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes

4.0


Expand filter menu Content Warnings