Scan barcode
crufts's review against another edition
adventurous
tense
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? No
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
After reading the Abhorsen trilogy something like 15 years ago, I heard about this new prequel book and was curious about it. Clariel reveals the sympathetic backstory of a villain from the main trilogy, although I didn't realize this until the end of the book.
So, how was it? Well...
There was nothing overtly wrong about the novel, and I didn't have any difficulty reaching the end. But it didn't have the same charm as the main trilogy.
Firstly, I had trouble attaching to Clariel as the main character. She's, uh... kind of a jock, I guess? Physically strong, not academically intelligent, and disinterested in the people around her, she just wants to escape from her noble family's expectations and go live in the forest.
I respected Clariel for being stubborn, headstrong, and refusing to take guff from anybody. But I didn't like her, and I didn't find her interesting. Her desire to live in the wild and escape the problems of city life is her most humanizing attribute, but she spends the majority of the book dealing with other issues that come up. Also, wanting to live in a forest isn't the kind of ambitious, dramatic, exciting, matter-of-life-or-death dream that I'd hope for in a protagonist.
When Mogget showed up, he was so much more interesting as a character that he basically stole the show.
That said, I did appreciate the asexual representation.
Secondly, Clariel didn't have the worldbuilding that I enjoyed in the main trilogy. Sabriel did the heavy lifting, introducing us to the Charter and the bells. Lirael expanded the world further by diving into the Clayr. Even Abhorsen had some spicy character reveals.
But Clariel didn't offer the same level of worldbuilding. The bells, the Charter, free magic, etc are all the same as before.
One thing I do like in the book (and the entire series) is the lack of sexism. Amongst many other examples, Clariel's mother is the breadwinner of the family while her father is effectively a stay-at-home dad. Nobody blinks an eye at Clariel's athleticism and other tomboyish traits: when her parents reprimand her for not being a "lady", they refer only to her gender-neutral duties as a noble heir. Meanwhile, important figures of state like the Abhorsen or guild leaders are just as likely to be women as men.
This was really refreshing compared to many other fantasy novels where sexism features heavily, even if all the goodie characters are staunchly against it.
Overall, the book was okay.
So, how was it? Well...
There was nothing overtly wrong about the novel, and I didn't have any difficulty reaching the end. But it didn't have the same charm as the main trilogy.
Firstly, I had trouble attaching to Clariel as the main character. She's, uh... kind of a jock, I guess? Physically strong, not academically intelligent, and disinterested in the people around her, she just wants to escape from her noble family's expectations and go live in the forest.
I respected Clariel for being stubborn, headstrong, and refusing to take guff from anybody. But I didn't like her, and I didn't find her interesting. Her desire to live in the wild and escape the problems of city life is her most humanizing attribute, but she spends the majority of the book dealing with other issues that come up. Also, wanting to live in a forest isn't the kind of ambitious, dramatic, exciting, matter-of-life-or-death dream that I'd hope for in a protagonist.
When Mogget showed up, he was so much more interesting as a character that he basically stole the show.
That said, I did appreciate the asexual representation.
Secondly, Clariel didn't have the worldbuilding that I enjoyed in the main trilogy. Sabriel did the heavy lifting, introducing us to the Charter and the bells. Lirael expanded the world further by diving into the Clayr. Even Abhorsen had some spicy character reveals.
But Clariel didn't offer the same level of worldbuilding. The bells, the Charter, free magic, etc are all the same as before.
One thing I do like in the book (and the entire series) is the lack of sexism. Amongst many other examples, Clariel's mother is the breadwinner of the family while her father is effectively a stay-at-home dad. Nobody blinks an eye at Clariel's athleticism and other tomboyish traits: when her parents reprimand her for not being a "lady", they refer only to her gender-neutral duties as a noble heir. Meanwhile, important figures of state like the Abhorsen or guild leaders are just as likely to be women as men.
This was really refreshing compared to many other fantasy novels where sexism features heavily, even if all the goodie characters are staunchly against it.
Overall, the book was okay.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Violence
Minor: Confinement and Grief
Clariel deals with a few awkward situations on account of her asexuality, but nothing downright acephobic.bluejay21's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
mysterious
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? It's complicated
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
Content Warnings
Graphic: Death, Death of parent, Gore, Injury/Injury detail, and Violence
Moderate: Blood, Confinement, Grief, and Kidnapping
aylaravenstar's review
adventurous
challenging
dark
funny
mysterious
slow-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.0
Clariel was much harder to get through than the others in the Old Kingdom series, though overall I did enjoy it. The main character was hard to like, but it's a worthwhile read if you're planning on continuing the series.
Content Warnings
Moderate: Death
Minor: Blood, Confinement, and Grief
More...