Scan barcode
fyziksgirl's review
challenging
dark
emotional
reflective
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? No
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
3.5
Katherine Applegate is one of my favorite children's authors, but this book did not do it for me.
From the description I expected an adventure to find forever families, but really the portion where the characters leave the shelter is very short. Most of the book takes place in the shelter, complete with all the sad things that happen in a shelter, like getting to the top of "the list" and dogs thinking they're going to be put down. It is a very sad, anxiety-inducing book, and it feels like much of the point was to really emphasize to kids how terrible shelters are, which is a hard thing to put on them when kids cannot do much to materially help the situation without significant parent buy-in.
There's also a lot of ableism in this book, and though it's relatively low key, it's there and was hard to read as a disabled family. There's a ton of talk about how no one wants to see a dog with 3 legs and it is depressing to be around them. This is contradicted at the VERY end, but 99% of the book it is talked about as a given and an accepted thing everyone knows. They also talk about how no family would want an older dog because they'll have more vet bills. While this is true for dogs and dog adoptions, when you're anthropomorphizing the dogs to make them relatable to humans and like human stand-ins for deeper meaning, it sends a rough message to children (and adults) who need regular doctor visits and medical care and can feel like a burden on their family for it.
There's a nonspeaking autistic boy who visits the shelter and the happy arc of his story is how he begins talking and "entering the world in a way he never has," and while connection is necessary and good for humans, the whole thing has an off, ableist vibe in how it was framed. When he has a meltdown (partially from adults pushing him into it), he is suspended from returning; it is acknowledged it happened because of his disability not a choice but him, but the book treats as a given that it's a reasonable response to punish him for his disability and never acknowledges the responsibility of the adults in the situation. The human characters do care about him, though, the ableism was low-key, it just gave me the ick.
Overall a much sadder book than I was expecting. I thought it would be a hope-filled adventure, but it is mostly a depressing story of being stuck in a hard situation without the main character even looking to improve her life or imagining she could. It was 2 stars most of the way through for me, but at the end it bumped up to 3.5.
Definitely don't read if you've lost a dog recently.
From the description I expected an adventure to find forever families, but really the portion where the characters leave the shelter is very short. Most of the book takes place in the shelter, complete with all the sad things that happen in a shelter, like getting to the top of "the list" and dogs thinking they're going to be put down. It is a very sad, anxiety-inducing book, and it feels like much of the point was to really emphasize to kids how terrible shelters are, which is a hard thing to put on them when kids cannot do much to materially help the situation without significant parent buy-in.
There's also a lot of ableism in this book, and though it's relatively low key, it's there and was hard to read as a disabled family. There's a ton of talk about how no one wants to see a dog with 3 legs and it is depressing to be around them.
There's a nonspeaking autistic boy who visits the shelter and the happy arc of his story is how he begins talking and "entering the world in a way he never has," and while connection is necessary and good for humans, the whole thing has an off, ableist vibe in how it was framed. When he has a meltdown (partially from adults pushing him into it), he is suspended from returning; it is acknowledged it happened because of his disability not a choice but him, but the book treats as a given that it's a reasonable response to punish him for his disability and never acknowledges the responsibility of the adults in the situation. The human characters do care about him, though, the ableism was low-key, it just gave me the ick.
Overall a much sadder book than I was expecting. I thought it would be a hope-filled adventure, but it is mostly a depressing story of being stuck in a hard situation without the main character even looking to improve her life or imagining she could. It was 2 stars most of the way through for me, but at the end it bumped up to 3.5.
Definitely don't read if you've lost a dog recently.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Ableism
Moderate: Animal cruelty and Animal death
purplepenning's review
adventurous
emotional
funny
hopeful
medium-paced
4.25
Content Warnings
Moderate: Confinement, Excrement, Abandonment, and Grief
Minor: Car accident, Animal cruelty, Animal death, and Injury/Injury detail
readingwithmeredith's review against another edition
adventurous
emotional
hopeful
inspiring
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? A mix
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? N/A
- Flaws of characters a main focus? It's complicated
3.5
Content Warnings
Moderate: Animal cruelty, Abandonment, and Grief
atamano's review
emotional
fast-paced
4.25
Content Warnings
Graphic: Abandonment, Forced institutionalization, and Grief
Moderate: Injury/Injury detail, Medical trauma, Ableism, Animal cruelty, and Car accident
Minor: Animal death and Excrement
leahgustafson's review
adventurous
emotional
funny
lighthearted
fast-paced
5.0
I am so grateful to NetGalley, Katherine Applegate, and Gennifer Choldenko for the advanced copy of this phenomenal new middle grade book (out September 19th). I absolutely adore this one!
•
This book is set in a shelter (Dogtown) where Chance and other dogs have found themselves due to a variety of unfortunate circumstances. These “flesh and blood” dogs ban together against the robot dogs who are also at the shelter and are now very popular among humans. Things take an interesting turn when Chance is asked to help Metal Head, one of the robot dogs.
•
I love how this book portrays the loving, loyal, goodness of dogs. The way the dogs in this story love and long for their humans reminds me that we, as humans, are not worthy of our dogs. The friendship between the dogs (and Mouse) remind me of the friendship/bonds in The One and Only Ivan. This made my heart SO happy! Dogtown is also a great story about having compassion for others who may be different from you and the importance of getting to know people (and their story).
•
Wallace West's illustrations throughout this entire text were adorable. I know this will become a read aloud favorite in my 3rd grade classroom for years to come! I have already told so many of my students from last year about it.
•
Check out what I'm reading next on Instagram @LeahsLitReview!
Check out what I'm reading next on Instagram @LeahsLitReview!
Content Warnings
Moderate: Animal cruelty
More...