Scan barcode
m_is_for_awesome's review
3.0
A fun, fast paced, and light hearted science-fantasty in space with dastardly villains and classic heroes! I love the ships in this, and the space battles are excellent!
I have to admit however, I liked book 1 better, because the humans in book 2 detracted from the fun. I had issues with them, the captain most of all.
The captain Serengeti mourned for in book 1 is...well he suffers in a state of dated, toxic behaviour so thick I just couldn't get why sweet, smart, powerful Serengeti puts up with it. Why he is presented as a 'hero' at all.
He doesn't want help when he's injured ("Last thing I need is some damned nursemaid fawning all over me."), doesn't really value book learning ("Math? What math? What the hell does math have to do with any of this?"...they are discussing navigation and orbits in space which is uh, very involved with math), uses questionable slurs ("Pansy-ass coward"), and judges people on their waistline ("Guy that fat's been workin' a desk for a while, which means he's pompous and self-important").
It was so off-putting it took me four months to finish the book - drawn back by Serengeti, and repelled by the captain over and over. BUT I am glad I did finish it - the ending is full of lovely lovely space battles.
I have to admit however, I liked book 1 better, because the humans in book 2 detracted from the fun. I had issues with them, the captain most of all.
The captain Serengeti mourned for in book 1 is...well he suffers in a state of dated, toxic behaviour so thick I just couldn't get why sweet, smart, powerful Serengeti puts up with it. Why he is presented as a 'hero' at all.
He doesn't want help when he's injured ("Last thing I need is some damned nursemaid fawning all over me."), doesn't really value book learning ("Math? What math? What the hell does math have to do with any of this?"...they are discussing navigation and orbits in space which is uh, very involved with math), uses questionable slurs ("Pansy-ass coward"), and judges people on their waistline ("Guy that fat's been workin' a desk for a while, which means he's pompous and self-important").
It was so off-putting it took me four months to finish the book - drawn back by Serengeti, and repelled by the captain over and over. BUT I am glad I did finish it - the ending is full of lovely lovely space battles.
lilyn_g's review
4.0
I read J.B. Rockwell’s Serengeti at the beginning of the year and liked it. I believe I described it as one part massive space battle, two parts Wall-E 2. It was a pleasant surprise that left me with a surprising amount of ‘feels’ I didn’t expect to feel about a spaceship. So, I initially resisted reading Dark and Stars for the same reason I resist reading a lot of sequels. The fact that there was a strong chance the sequel was going to – if not outright suck – not be anywhere near as good as the first one. There have only been a handful of times where it’s gone in the opposite direction.
But then the author offered me an audiobook version for review, and I caved. I love my audiobooks.
So, let me get this out of the way right away. The narrator for Dark and Stars sucked. She was not the right voice for this book. She read the book like it was a children’s book most of the time. The voices were overly exaggerated, and the English accent just did not fit at all. At one point I remember commenting to someone that the narrator gave me this mental picture of Julie Andrews. Julie Andrews as a Valkyrie spaceship mercilessly mowing down those who get in her way. Let that one sink in until you see exactly how disturbing it is. And the voice she used for Oona made me hunch my shoulders and wince every time I heard it. Dear sweet baby Cthulhu, that voice was one of the most annoying ones I’ve ever heard!
To give the narrator some credit, though, the saccharine sweet voice did make some of the insults, quips, and cursing rather unexpectedly hilarious. (And yes, even though the narrator reads it like a kid book, this is not a kid book. There’s a fair amount of situational appropriate cursing involved.)
Dark and Stars, however, did not suck. It did not suck at all. In fact, Dark and Stars was actually better than the first book.
J.B. Rockwell has a talent for writing battles. I’m always able to visualize what exactly is happening, and find myself on the edge of my seat. When it got to the long-awaited main battle in Dark and Stars, I found myself holding my breath and driving a little slower than I should have to give myself more time before I had to disengage from the story.
As for characters, even if I did not care for them all, they are memorable. I love Serengeti and Henricksen, of course. Those two are a match made in the stars. The interactions between them are full of mutual respect and snark, and they work together extremely well. Finley is another fun character, and has probably my favorite line in the whole book.
Likewise, Tig and Tilly and are fun little robots, and there’s a scene involving guns that had me laughing out loud.
I do have the same problem, however, with Dark and Stars that I had with Serengeti. That being that I just can’t buy the humanity of the AI. Serengeti herself I eventually adapted to, but Oona… Well, Oona is, in my opinion, the weakest point in the book. The only way I can justify her behavior is that she’s absolutely brilliant and deliberately acting like a 2 year old to disarm people. It’s a computer mind, I just can’t see a computer unintentionally mangling a word like she often does. It, pardon the pun, does not compute. But even with that justification, it still bothers me. I can’t help it. Actually, one of the other characters – a stealth ship – is another character that’s a little hard to believe in. But I won’t say more on that because I’m not sure how much of it is pure distaste from the voice the narrator gave him.
There is one other thing involving Oona. It’s not necessarily a bad thing, but her role in the plot of Dark and Stars is obvious. I didn’t mind it, because it gave me a bit of reassurance, but it does dial back on the potential ‘surprise’ in store later on. Other people might not think it’s as obvious as it is. I’m fully willing to admit that I read so much that there’s very little that can surprise me anymore.
The pacing in Dark and Stars is fantastic. Right from the moment it begins, you know that something isn’t right. Then, as time goes on, and more is revealed, the tension ratchets up until you just want the climactic fight scene to happen already! I was completely wrapped up in Serengeti’s adventures in this book. The fact that I had to keep stopping to adult (or sleep) had me so irritated! The final battle had me yelling at my phone. I can’t tell you what I was yelling because of spoilers, but take my word for it – definitely yelling!
From the memorable characters to a plot that sucks you in completely, and kick-butt battle scenes to boot, Dark and Stars is a fantastic follow-up to Serengeti. JB Rockwell manages to give readers a sequel that feels fresh and strong and proves her talent.
(I went back and forth between four and five stars for quite a while before decided that four stars was just barely a better fit than five, given the issues I had – not counting the narrator choice - . It’s really more of a 4.5.)
-----------
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book free from the author for review consideration.
Additional disclaimer: I have friendly interactions with the author who participates in events I host quite regularly, as well as does a bad movie review once a month on my site. However, as the criticisms I laid out in the review above should clearly indicate, that does not influence my review of the book one way or another.
But then the author offered me an audiobook version for review, and I caved. I love my audiobooks.
So, let me get this out of the way right away. The narrator for Dark and Stars sucked. She was not the right voice for this book. She read the book like it was a children’s book most of the time. The voices were overly exaggerated, and the English accent just did not fit at all. At one point I remember commenting to someone that the narrator gave me this mental picture of Julie Andrews. Julie Andrews as a Valkyrie spaceship mercilessly mowing down those who get in her way. Let that one sink in until you see exactly how disturbing it is. And the voice she used for Oona made me hunch my shoulders and wince every time I heard it. Dear sweet baby Cthulhu, that voice was one of the most annoying ones I’ve ever heard!
To give the narrator some credit, though, the saccharine sweet voice did make some of the insults, quips, and cursing rather unexpectedly hilarious. (And yes, even though the narrator reads it like a kid book, this is not a kid book. There’s a fair amount of situational appropriate cursing involved.)
Dark and Stars, however, did not suck. It did not suck at all. In fact, Dark and Stars was actually better than the first book.
J.B. Rockwell has a talent for writing battles. I’m always able to visualize what exactly is happening, and find myself on the edge of my seat. When it got to the long-awaited main battle in Dark and Stars, I found myself holding my breath and driving a little slower than I should have to give myself more time before I had to disengage from the story.
As for characters, even if I did not care for them all, they are memorable. I love Serengeti and Henricksen, of course. Those two are a match made in the stars. The interactions between them are full of mutual respect and snark, and they work together extremely well. Finley is another fun character, and has probably my favorite line in the whole book.
“Why thank you! I was gonna kick him in the nuts, but Poppa raised me to be a lady.”
Likewise, Tig and Tilly and are fun little robots, and there’s a scene involving guns that had me laughing out loud.
I do have the same problem, however, with Dark and Stars that I had with Serengeti. That being that I just can’t buy the humanity of the AI. Serengeti herself I eventually adapted to, but Oona… Well, Oona is, in my opinion, the weakest point in the book. The only way I can justify her behavior is that she’s absolutely brilliant and deliberately acting like a 2 year old to disarm people. It’s a computer mind, I just can’t see a computer unintentionally mangling a word like she often does. It, pardon the pun, does not compute. But even with that justification, it still bothers me. I can’t help it. Actually, one of the other characters – a stealth ship – is another character that’s a little hard to believe in. But I won’t say more on that because I’m not sure how much of it is pure distaste from the voice the narrator gave him.
There is one other thing involving Oona. It’s not necessarily a bad thing, but her role in the plot of Dark and Stars is obvious. I didn’t mind it, because it gave me a bit of reassurance, but it does dial back on the potential ‘surprise’ in store later on. Other people might not think it’s as obvious as it is. I’m fully willing to admit that I read so much that there’s very little that can surprise me anymore.
The pacing in Dark and Stars is fantastic. Right from the moment it begins, you know that something isn’t right. Then, as time goes on, and more is revealed, the tension ratchets up until you just want the climactic fight scene to happen already! I was completely wrapped up in Serengeti’s adventures in this book. The fact that I had to keep stopping to adult (or sleep) had me so irritated! The final battle had me yelling at my phone. I can’t tell you what I was yelling because of spoilers, but take my word for it – definitely yelling!
From the memorable characters to a plot that sucks you in completely, and kick-butt battle scenes to boot, Dark and Stars is a fantastic follow-up to Serengeti. JB Rockwell manages to give readers a sequel that feels fresh and strong and proves her talent.
(I went back and forth between four and five stars for quite a while before decided that four stars was just barely a better fit than five, given the issues I had – not counting the narrator choice - . It’s really more of a 4.5.)
-----------
Disclaimer: I received a copy of this book free from the author for review consideration.
Additional disclaimer: I have friendly interactions with the author who participates in events I host quite regularly, as well as does a bad movie review once a month on my site. However, as the criticisms I laid out in the review above should clearly indicate, that does not influence my review of the book one way or another.
kateshaw's review
5.0
An awesome sequel to a fantastic book! I loved coming back to visit Serengeti and her world. Serengeti's frustration with the secrecy and intrigues surrounding her return is well expressed without being drawn out too long before she takes control. The story is full of fun surprises and lots of action!
More...