Scan barcode
librariandest's review against another edition
3.0
Here are my thoughts on this book:
1. It's a love story between a boy and a cat. And I mean like boy-meets-cat, boy-wants-cat, boy-gets-cat, boy-loses-cat, boy-gets-cat-back.
2. Most of it reads like the narration of a wildlife documentary. We learn all about the habits of cats, mice, owls, raccoons, deer, etc.
3. The cat illustrations aren't exactly bad, but they're not cute.
4. I enjoyed reading it, even though it felt overtly educational and the boy said ridiculous things no teenage boy I've met would ever say like, "Drat!" and "That cry was the male cat caterwauling for his female."
5. There was something so old-fashioned about this book (see the boy's quotes above), even though there were allusions to global warming and electric rail. Certainly some people will say this is boring and/or cheesy.
6. I would recommend this to young nature/cat lovers, but the reading level is fairly sophisticated for such an innocent cat book, so it's a tough call age-wise.
1. It's a love story between a boy and a cat. And I mean like boy-meets-cat, boy-wants-cat, boy-gets-cat, boy-loses-cat, boy-gets-cat-back.
2. Most of it reads like the narration of a wildlife documentary. We learn all about the habits of cats, mice, owls, raccoons, deer, etc.
3. The cat illustrations aren't exactly bad, but they're not cute.
4. I enjoyed reading it, even though it felt overtly educational and the boy said ridiculous things no teenage boy I've met would ever say like, "Drat!" and "That cry was the male cat caterwauling for his female."
5. There was something so old-fashioned about this book (see the boy's quotes above), even though there were allusions to global warming and electric rail. Certainly some people will say this is boring and/or cheesy.
6. I would recommend this to young nature/cat lovers, but the reading level is fairly sophisticated for such an innocent cat book, so it's a tough call age-wise.
marmoset737's review against another edition
5.0
Kitties! Seriously though - this is a great chapter book particularly for kids who love reading about animals. The environment (a run-down suburb that's being more and more industrialized) and the human characters (including a foster kid who's learning how to get along with his sometimes distant foster mother and a lonely cat-person) are unique and well-drawn. But at the heart of the book is the cats themselves, and George is never condescending in her depiction of the lives of feral cats giving kids (and adults) an appreciation of the solitary lifestyle of cats, and the dangers that face feral cats.
lindzt18's review against another edition
hopeful
informative
lighthearted
reflective
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
4.0
Such a surprisingly poignant book about the lives of feral cats that beautifully explains all of their unique habits. A sweet book but definitely a warning for animal death— it is always explained simply, but the book does not shy away from it, so caution with younger readers.
Content Warnings
Minor: Animal death, Animal cruelty, and Death of parent
kmarie75's review against another edition
3.0
Overall this was a fun book my nine year old cat lover enjoyed reading and sharing with me. However, he became very upset by two scenes that included the deaths of kittens. I understand the author wanted to stay true to the experiences of cats, but for an extremely sensitive child it was too much.
shibi's review against another edition
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
2.75
Content Warnings
Graphic: Animal cruelty and Animal death
pussreboots's review against another edition
5.0
Every book has a story. With favorite books, I often remember how I found the book (or how it found me) and where I was when I read it. In the case of The Cats of Roxville Station by Jean Cragihead George, the memory is on the finding of the book.
We were in San Ramon checking out a new and used book store, one of those places that shelves the old and the new together. It was late afternoon and the sunlight was streaming into the children's wing of the store. I was looking for a copy of The Hunger Games. My daughter distracted me as I reached for it and I pulled the book directly under it out: The Cats of Roxville Station.
The cover immediately caught my eye: a gorgeous, realistic water color of cats at a train station. I like cats and I like trains. I flipped through the book was further smitten by Tom Pohrt's line drawings.
The story, though told from an omniscient point of view, in the style of Richard Adams, is about Rachet, an abandoned cat who is dumped in a river at the edge of a thriving feral cat colony. She survives the attempted drowning and slowly begins to find her place at Roxville Station.
Through her attempts we are introduced the other cats and the humans who share the same space. The cats are for the most part just part of the surroundings. They aren't seen as potential pets or helpful for their ratting abilities. In fact one woman wants to have them exterminated but she doesn't realize a hole in her basement window is allowing some of them in at night.
The one truly sympathetic human is a young boy named Mike but his foster family won't allow him to have Rachet as a pet. He begins to make plans to give her a home he feels she deserves without risking his own current home situation.
The book is frank in its portrayal of people living around feral cats. While it does gloss over some details here and there it's by no means a rose-tinted story of cats living on their own. It's a dangerous life style for the cats. But it's beautifully told and it can be used to show children why its important to spay and neuter pets and why pets should be adopted from shelters if possible.
We were in San Ramon checking out a new and used book store, one of those places that shelves the old and the new together. It was late afternoon and the sunlight was streaming into the children's wing of the store. I was looking for a copy of The Hunger Games. My daughter distracted me as I reached for it and I pulled the book directly under it out: The Cats of Roxville Station.
The cover immediately caught my eye: a gorgeous, realistic water color of cats at a train station. I like cats and I like trains. I flipped through the book was further smitten by Tom Pohrt's line drawings.
The story, though told from an omniscient point of view, in the style of Richard Adams, is about Rachet, an abandoned cat who is dumped in a river at the edge of a thriving feral cat colony. She survives the attempted drowning and slowly begins to find her place at Roxville Station.
Through her attempts we are introduced the other cats and the humans who share the same space. The cats are for the most part just part of the surroundings. They aren't seen as potential pets or helpful for their ratting abilities. In fact one woman wants to have them exterminated but she doesn't realize a hole in her basement window is allowing some of them in at night.
The one truly sympathetic human is a young boy named Mike but his foster family won't allow him to have Rachet as a pet. He begins to make plans to give her a home he feels she deserves without risking his own current home situation.
The book is frank in its portrayal of people living around feral cats. While it does gloss over some details here and there it's by no means a rose-tinted story of cats living on their own. It's a dangerous life style for the cats. But it's beautifully told and it can be used to show children why its important to spay and neuter pets and why pets should be adopted from shelters if possible.
More...