Scan barcode
abaugher's review against another edition
5.0
wooo hoooo! excellent mystery! i LIKE kevin Brooks style!
awxhhlilla's review against another edition
adventurous
dark
funny
hopeful
informative
sad
tense
medium-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Character
- Strong character development? Yes
- Loveable characters? Yes
- Diverse cast of characters? Yes
- Flaws of characters a main focus? No
5.0
Content Warnings
Moderate: Child death, Blood, Mental illness, Sexual content, Suicide, Animal cruelty, Drug use, Animal death, Grief, Injury/Injury detail, Alcohol, Death, Fire/Fire injury, Cursing, and Murder
Minor: Bullying
butteredtoastinbed's review against another edition
dark
emotional
mysterious
reflective
sad
tense
fast-paced
- Plot- or character-driven? Plot
- Strong character development? It's complicated
- Loveable characters? It's complicated
- Diverse cast of characters? No
- Flaws of characters a main focus? Yes
4.0
I did enjoy this book for the most part and it was mysterious and unique enough to keep me thoroughly engaged through the whole story.
One of my favourite aspects of the novel was how gradually the pieces of the mystery were revealed to the main character (and to me as the reader); the slow revelation of the story building up was a lot of fun and did keep me engaged as the story panned out. Additionally, I thought the settings were really well written and I never had trouble with visualising a location (which I find to be rare). I also really liked one of the characters which helped to keep my motivation up and keep me engaged through the book to see how the story played out in regards to them.
Having said this though, there was only one character that I really cared about which did bother me as usually in books a lovable set of characters are important. Although, this wasn’t enough of an issue for me to become disinterested. Looking back, there was also a large section of roughly 100 pages in the middle of the novel where it felt a bit slow and unnecessary, where nothing really happened. However, at the time of reading I didn’t really notice this and it didn’t impact my enjoyment of the story at the time either.
As well as this, the twists weren’t especially shocking or unexpected - I saw a couple of them coming from far away, but I still enjoyed the revelation and how that continued to play out in the story, so it didn’t impact my reading experience too much.
All in all, I think of this novel more positively than negatively: it was interesting, unique and drew me in really quickly. Although I’m unlikely to reread this book soon I would still recommend it, especially to those who like a YA mystery.
One of my favourite aspects of the novel was how gradually the pieces of the mystery were revealed to the main character (and to me as the reader); the slow revelation of the story building up was a lot of fun and did keep me engaged as the story panned out. Additionally, I thought the settings were really well written and I never had trouble with visualising a location (which I find to be rare). I also really liked one of the characters which helped to keep my motivation up and keep me engaged through the book to see how the story played out in regards to them.
Having said this though, there was only one character that I really cared about which did bother me as usually in books a lovable set of characters are important. Although, this wasn’t enough of an issue for me to become disinterested. Looking back, there was also a large section of roughly 100 pages in the middle of the novel where it felt a bit slow and unnecessary, where nothing really happened. However, at the time of reading I didn’t really notice this and it didn’t impact my enjoyment of the story at the time either.
As well as this, the twists weren’t especially shocking or unexpected - I saw a couple of them coming from far away, but I still enjoyed the revelation and how that continued to play out in the story, so it didn’t impact my reading experience too much.
All in all, I think of this novel more positively than negatively: it was interesting, unique and drew me in really quickly. Although I’m unlikely to reread this book soon I would still recommend it, especially to those who like a YA mystery.
Content Warnings
Graphic: Grief and Death
Moderate: Animal cruelty, Mental illness, Alcohol, Blood, Murder, Animal death, Drug use, and Bullying
ljeanbean's review against another edition
5.0
This book deserves a thousand stars! SO AMAZING I mean really.
readwithpassion's review against another edition
4.0
I am a huge Kevin Brooks fan. The middle of this one was a bit slow for me, but overall, I loved it. It wasn't as good as Kevin Brooks' Road of the Dead, Being, or Lucas, but I thought it tops his Martyn Pig and Kissing the Rain.
Loved it!
Loved it!
dananoel's review against another edition
2.0
I read this book back in the good ole days of seventh grade, I believe. It was at least around seventh grade, because as I read it, I noticed a TON of similarities between Brooks’ writing and my own ancient scripts. I guess I thought he was a master or something? Reading it now, I can’t help but skim some pages because it’s repetitive, nothing really happens, etc. I remember at the time I couldn’t stop reading it, and this proved true ten years later.
So the basic story line: a group of teenagers decide to meet up one summer, I’m guessing the summer after their last year of high school. They used to be BFFs. There is Pauly, the goof ball who can make everyone laugh and who’s pretty dumb but in a fun way; Eric, the one who’s pretty serious about things but is generally a nice guy; Nicole, Eric’s twin, who has an intimate history with Pete; Pete, the narrator, the main guy, Nicole’s love interest, really annoying; and finally Raymond, Pete’s BFF despite the group dynamic falling apart. Raymond is different, a little off. It never says specifically what’s wrong with Raymond – Pete denies anything is actually wrong with him, he’s just a kid who’s been through a lot of bullying and his parents are neglectful and he says he hears voices in his head, particularly the voice of a black rabbit he keeps as a pet. Pauly, Eric, and Nicole have never cared too much for Raymond, but have tolerated him for Pete. They meet up at an old hang out spot, and things suck. They’re all so different. They drink and smoke and Nicole unsuccessfully seduces Pete once the others have left. When this fails, Pete walks to the fairgrounds, where a carnival is being held, and where the others are waiting for them.
It takes Pete a while to find Raymond, and when he does, Raymond is walking around with Stella Ross, a recent movie-star, and her cameramen. Stella is obviously using him to a) make herself look good by hanging out with what people consider a charity case and b) just to be a bitch and mess around with him. Pete tells her to fuck off and takes Raymond away. They visit a fortune teller (always a bad sign) who says Raymond is in trouble and tells Pete to watch out for him. Coincidentally, Raymond has been babbling about “Star’s going out tonight,” something the black rabbit has been saying to him, along with other weird delusional-type ramblings that Pete doesn’t really take into consideration. Well, Pete has to take a piss and leaves Raymond to stand outside the “Portaloo” for half a second. When he comes out, Raymond is gone.
The next morning, Stella Ross has disappeared as well. Pete goes over to Raymond’s house and finds the black rabbit has been decapitated, the head impaled on a gate.
As much as I get his position in all of this, Pete is so fucking annoying. He keeps holding things back from the police that he has no reason to hold back. If he wouldn’t LIE, the book would be 200 pages shorter. This is a common occurrence in mysteries, unfortunately. It doesn’t add to the suspense; it just pisses me off. Pete is running around upset because Raymond is missing and evidence is piling on against him, but Pete’s not helping the cause!! All he’s doing is being vague and acting stupid.
Everyone else was stupid and annoying too. It turns out Pauly, Eric, and Eric’s lover Wes were all involved in the accidental killing of Stella. Her body is found in the river and everything. It was accidental, but mostly Pauly’s fault. Then Pauly kills himself. And that’s that. And guess what?
We still don’t know what happened to Raymond.
I don’t give a fuck about Stella Ross! I wanted to know what happened to the only likable character in the whole MF book!!! What an outrage. Did I even finish this book ten years ago? What would possibly make me think this was gold?
What a hot mess.
So the basic story line: a group of teenagers decide to meet up one summer, I’m guessing the summer after their last year of high school. They used to be BFFs. There is Pauly, the goof ball who can make everyone laugh and who’s pretty dumb but in a fun way; Eric, the one who’s pretty serious about things but is generally a nice guy; Nicole, Eric’s twin, who has an intimate history with Pete; Pete, the narrator, the main guy, Nicole’s love interest, really annoying; and finally Raymond, Pete’s BFF despite the group dynamic falling apart. Raymond is different, a little off. It never says specifically what’s wrong with Raymond – Pete denies anything is actually wrong with him, he’s just a kid who’s been through a lot of bullying and his parents are neglectful and he says he hears voices in his head, particularly the voice of a black rabbit he keeps as a pet. Pauly, Eric, and Nicole have never cared too much for Raymond, but have tolerated him for Pete. They meet up at an old hang out spot, and things suck. They’re all so different. They drink and smoke and Nicole unsuccessfully seduces Pete once the others have left. When this fails, Pete walks to the fairgrounds, where a carnival is being held, and where the others are waiting for them.
It takes Pete a while to find Raymond, and when he does, Raymond is walking around with Stella Ross, a recent movie-star, and her cameramen. Stella is obviously using him to a) make herself look good by hanging out with what people consider a charity case and b) just to be a bitch and mess around with him. Pete tells her to fuck off and takes Raymond away. They visit a fortune teller (always a bad sign) who says Raymond is in trouble and tells Pete to watch out for him. Coincidentally, Raymond has been babbling about “Star’s going out tonight,” something the black rabbit has been saying to him, along with other weird delusional-type ramblings that Pete doesn’t really take into consideration. Well, Pete has to take a piss and leaves Raymond to stand outside the “Portaloo” for half a second. When he comes out, Raymond is gone.
The next morning, Stella Ross has disappeared as well. Pete goes over to Raymond’s house and finds the black rabbit has been decapitated, the head impaled on a gate.
Spoiler
The police start investigating the disappearances of both Raymond and Stella, asking Pete and the others questions about the night of the fair. They find Stella’s clothes near a river, covered with her blood, along with a necklace and a pebble with a rabbit scraped into the surface. It is starting to look like Raymond is involved in the disappearance of Stella; however, the others: Pauly, Nicole, and Eric, are all being super suspicious as well. So, the book goes into a “all are suspects” trope, one of my absolute favorites.As much as I get his position in all of this, Pete is so fucking annoying. He keeps holding things back from the police that he has no reason to hold back. If he wouldn’t LIE, the book would be 200 pages shorter. This is a common occurrence in mysteries, unfortunately. It doesn’t add to the suspense; it just pisses me off. Pete is running around upset because Raymond is missing and evidence is piling on against him, but Pete’s not helping the cause!! All he’s doing is being vague and acting stupid.
Everyone else was stupid and annoying too. It turns out Pauly, Eric, and Eric’s lover Wes were all involved in the accidental killing of Stella. Her body is found in the river and everything. It was accidental, but mostly Pauly’s fault. Then Pauly kills himself. And that’s that. And guess what?
We still don’t know what happened to Raymond.
I don’t give a fuck about Stella Ross! I wanted to know what happened to the only likable character in the whole MF book!!! What an outrage. Did I even finish this book ten years ago? What would possibly make me think this was gold?
What a hot mess.
chadstep's review against another edition
5.0
I don't consider myself a mystery reader but this truly grabbed me. It lacked the qualities I dislike in mysteries--the intrepid investigator goodie-goodie/outsider, missing scenes that "hide" a way for the reader to discover the truth, the feeling I get like when I am being les through a maze like a mouse to cheese--which have been part of my reading past that make them boring or distasteful or like trying to scramble up a solid wall without hope.
Black Rabbit Summer had youth, class divisions, English law enforcement, boredom, and even occult-ish aspects that made it enticing. Great one-step-ahead of the law/media feeling and the suspicion of youth which is, of course, misread by the adult community, especially the innocence-gone-wrong moments throughout that definitely made me think, "yeah, that could have been me and my friends" in a fictionalized way. Very trim dialogue and not too much preachy, moralizing. Thanks, Kevin, for making me come back to mysteries.
Black Rabbit Summer had youth, class divisions, English law enforcement, boredom, and even occult-ish aspects that made it enticing. Great one-step-ahead of the law/media feeling and the suspicion of youth which is, of course, misread by the adult community, especially the innocence-gone-wrong moments throughout that definitely made me think, "yeah, that could have been me and my friends" in a fictionalized way. Very trim dialogue and not too much preachy, moralizing. Thanks, Kevin, for making me come back to mysteries.
nimra64672's review against another edition
4.0
The only thing I didn't like is that we don't find out what happened to Raymond ... However, you can easily assume what might have happened to him